Accounts conflict Who was obstructing supplies to Oleshky
Russia blamed Ukraine for obstructing supplies.
Ukraine said Russia was thwarting food deliveries.
Sources (1)
Ukraine · our summary of NDTV
On Oct. 16, Pope Leo XIV urged Vladimir Putin to arrange a truce for food and medical aid to Oleshky and the safe, voluntary evacuation of civilians; the Kremlin said Putin blamed Kyiv for conditions but backed Vatican efforts on residents’ safety and supplies and agreed to cooperate. Three days later, Leo discussed the crisis with Volodymyr Zelensky, who said Ukraine was working to help residents and that the pope had told him of contacts with Russia; The Kyiv Independent reported that about 2,000 residents remained trapped without enough food or medicine.
Summary written by our automated pipeline from the outlets' reporting. How it works
Grouped by where each speaker is from. Quotation marks are the speaker's own words; other lines are our summaries.
Leo XIV reaffirmed the Holy See's commitment to dialogue and peace.
Our summary of TASS · also 6 other outlets
“The pontiff expressed hope that cooperation between both sides would make it possible to deliver food and medical aid, as well as carry out the voluntary and safe evacuation of…”
Quoted in TASS · also 2 other outlets
“…to plead the cause of this besieged city”
Quoted in NDTV
“…called for a ceasefire to allow the delivery of food and medical assistance, and the voluntary and safe evacuation of the civilian population”
Quoted in South China Morning Post · also 4 other outlets
Putin backed the Vatican's intention to help ensure the safety of Alyoshki residents and organize vital supplies.
Our summary of TASS · also 1 other outlet
Putin reportedly placed responsibility for the humanitarian catastrophe on Ukraine during the call.
Our summary of Ukrainska Pravda, via Russian media
“The conversation was held in a constructive and mutually respectful manner”
Quoted in TASS · also 1 other outlet
“…the Vatican’s intention to help create conditions for ensuring the safety of the local population and facilitating the delivery of essential supplies”
Quoted in Fox News · also 1 other outlet
“We are working to help our people there and are preparing solutions”
Quoted in The Kyiv Independent
Ukraine said Russia is thwarting food deliveries to the town.
Our summary of NDTV
Points where outlets or parties give conflicting facts or readings. Each side is summarised by our pipeline; its sources are listed under it.
Russia blamed Ukraine for obstructing supplies.
Ukraine said Russia was thwarting food deliveries.
Ukraine · our summary of NDTV
Reactions from other countries and bodies, others involved, and commentary.
Danielle Bell said Oleshky is still home to around 1,700 residents, including 47 children.
Our summary of NDTV
Russian soldiers threaten to kill or rape residents if they do not hand over their food, according to Ukrainian residents.
Our summary of Clarín, via The Washington Post
Dubinin says the phone call cannot be expected to fundamentally change events or automatically resolve any of the difficult issues.
Our summary of RIA Novosti
“Мы не можем рассчитывать на то, что этот разговор сам по себе кардинально изменит ход событий”
No translation yet.
Aid organizations have long complained about the humanitarian situation in Oleschky.
Our summary of Der Spiegel · long-held position
The Tribunal for Putin warns of a possible war crime by Russia.
Our summary of El País · long-held position
On 16 October, Pope Leo XIV spoke by phone with Vladimir Putin and asked him to arrange a truce to enable aid deliveries to Oleshky and the safe, voluntary evacuation of civilians. The Kremlin said Putin blamed Kyiv for the humanitarian situation but backed Vatican efforts on residents’ safety and vital supplies, and that the sides agreed to cooperate.
Sources: Ukrainska Pravda (via Vatican News) · TASS · RIA Novosti
Pope Leo XIV called Putin on 16 October and asked him to organise a truce to deliver aid to Oleshky.
The Pope called for a ceasefire to allow delivery of food and medical assistance and the voluntary, safe evacuation of civilians from Oleshky.
“…a comprehensive explanation was provided regarding the Kiev regime’s responsibility for the difficult humanitarian situation there”
Putin supported the Vatican's intention to help ensure the safety of Aleshki residents and organize vital supplies.
The sides agreed to cooperate on this matter.
On 19 October, Pope Leo XIV spoke by phone with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky about Oleshky’s humanitarian situation. Leo expressed hope that cooperation would allow aid deliveries and safe, voluntary evacuation; Zelensky said Ukraine was working to help residents and that the pope had told him about contacts with Russia.
Sources: Ukrainska Pravda (via European Pravda) · TASS · The Kyiv Independent
Pope Leo XIV expressed the hope that cooperation between both parties would allow delivery of food and medical aid and voluntary and safe evacuation of civilians.
“The pontiff expressed hope that cooperation between both sides would make it possible to deliver food and medical aid, as well as carry out the voluntary and safe evacuation of…”
“We are working to help our people there and are preparing solutions”
“His Holiness informed me about his contacts with the Russian side regarding this issue”
Each outlet's headline, linked to its article. Non-English headlines are machine-translated. The groupings and notes on what each outlet emphasises are automated.
None of our outlets is based in Vatican.
Written by our automated pipeline from the statements in the coverage; each point lists the statements it rests on.
Leo’s appeal linked a ceasefire to aid deliveries and the voluntary, safe evacuation of civilians.
Holy See, Vatican government · our summary of Ukrainska Pravda, via Vatican News
Holy See, Vatican government · our summary of Ukrainska Pravda, via Vatican News
The Kremlin’s account paired blame of Kyiv for Oleshky’s humanitarian situation with support for Vatican aid efforts and an agreement to cooperate.
“…a comprehensive explanation was provided regarding the Kiev regime’s responsibility for the difficult humanitarian situation there”
Kremlin press service · our summary of RIA Novosti
Kremlin press service · our summary of RIA Novosti
Zelensky said Ukraine was working to help Oleshky residents and that Leo had told him about contacts with Russia.
“We are working to help our people there and are preparing solutions”
“His Holiness informed me about his contacts with the Russian side regarding this issue”
The Kyiv Independent reported that around 2,000 residents remained trapped without sufficient food or medicine.
Our summary of The Kyiv Independent
Publisher logos load from the publishers' own sites. Report an error on this page · Corrections
Official portrait of Volodymyr Zelenskyy, dated 26 August 2019. The file does not specify a place.
File:Volodymyr Zelensky Official portrait.jpg · http://www.president.gov.ua/ · CC BY 4.0
President.gov.ua
https://www.president.gov.ua/en/president/biografiya
Creator Original sourceCreative Commons Attribution 4.0