Zelensky and Trump discuss a possible energy truce
A story of 5 related events · arranged 25 Sep 08:19 UTC · Sources | Summary
Zelensky said Ukraine was ready to stop attacks on energy infrastructure if Russia agreed to reciprocal restraint. Trump said Russia and Ukraine had agreed to stop such attacks, while Russia said it would accept the proposal only if Western energy sanctions were lifted first. The accounts differ on whether a truce had been agreed; Zelensky said his meeting with Trump produced no agreement.
Key points
Ukraine’s offer was conditional on Russia also halting attacks on energy infrastructure.
Evidence · 3 source statements
"We are ready for any kind of format of energy ceasefire"
"not attack our energy system,"
Trump described the countries as having agreed to stop attacks, but Russia made its acceptance conditional on lifting Western energy sanctions.
Evidence · 2 source statements
Trump last week asserted that he got the two sides to agree to not target each other's energy infrastructure.
Russia said it could only go along with Trump's energy truce proposal if Western energy sanctions on Moscow were lifted first.
The United States said it would try to help broker a halt, while warning that an agreement would be difficult.
Evidence · 3 source statements
Later, at a news conference, Rubio said the Trump administration would try to get both sides to reach an agreement to halt attacks on Russian oil infrastructure and Ukrainian…
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,”
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,” he said, acknowledging that reaching such an agreement would not be easy, given that both sides…
Zelensky said his meeting with Trump was positive but produced no agreement.
Evidence · 2 source statements
"positive and productive,"
No agreements were reached, he said.
Who's involved
Volodymyr Zelensky · Ukraine
Ukraine’s president and the person who made the proposal on Ukraine’s behalf.
Ukraine was ready for an energy ceasefire if Russia accepted reciprocal terms. Zelensky said he did not know Moscow’s position, wanted the United States to convey the proposal, and was ready to meet Putin with Trump.
What they said · 5 source statements
"We are ready for any kind of format of energy ceasefire"
"not attack our energy system,"
he did not know Moscow's position
Zelenskyy said that he also was ready to meet the Russian president, Vladimir Putin, at a trilateral meeting with Trump.
Donald Trump · United States
The U.S. president, who discussed the proposal with Zelensky and has called for both countries to stop attacks.
Trump said Russia and Ukraine had agreed to stop attacks on each other’s energy infrastructure. He predicted a broader deal but did not disclose its terms.
What they said · 4 source statements
Trump last week asserted that he got the two sides to agree to not target each other's energy infrastructure.
I think they're going to make a deal
I don't want to say what the deal is.
Russia · Russia
Russia is a party to the war and would need to take part in any reciprocal halt.
Russia said it would accept the energy-truce proposal only if Western energy sanctions were lifted first.
What they said · 1 source statement
Russia said it could only go along with Trump's energy truce proposal if Western energy sanctions on Moscow were lifted first.
Marco Rubio · United States
As U.S. secretary of state, he described Washington’s efforts to facilitate an agreement.
Rubio said the United States would try to help the countries halt attacks on energy infrastructure, while warning that an agreement would be difficult.
What they said · 3 source statements
Later, at a news conference, Rubio said the Trump administration would try to get both sides to reach an agreement to halt attacks on Russian oil infrastructure and Ukrainian…
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,”
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,” he said, acknowledging that reaching such an agreement would not be easy, given that both sides…
Where accounts differ
Different readings
Whether Russia and Ukraine had agreed to an energy truce
Trump said the two countries had agreed not to target each other’s energy infrastructure.
Evidence · 2 source statements
Trump last week asserted that he got the two sides to agree to not target each other's energy infrastructure.
Zelensky described Ukraine as ready to agree only on reciprocal terms and said he did not know Moscow’s position; Russia said it would accept the proposal only if Western energy sanctions were lifted.
Evidence · 3 source statements
"not attack our energy system,"
he did not know Moscow's position
Russia said it could only go along with Trump's energy truce proposal if Western energy sanctions on Moscow were lifted first.
Trump described an agreement, while Ukraine’s stated offer was conditional and Russia also set a condition for acceptance.
Different readings
How successful the Trump-Zelensky meeting was
Zelensky called the meeting positive and productive but said no agreements were reached.
Evidence · 2 source statements
"positive and productive,"
No agreements were reached, he said.
Strana.ua reported that the meeting did not meet Kyiv’s expectations and that no concrete decisions were made.
Evidence · 2 source statements
The accounts differ in their assessment of the meeting, though both say it produced no agreement or concrete decision.
How it unfolded
Mid-September — Trump called for Russia and Ukraine to stop attacks on energy facilities.
Evidence · 1 source statement
The previous week — Trump announced an energy truce and said Russia and Ukraine had agreed not to target each other’s energy infrastructure.
Evidence · 2 source statements
The US president announced such a truce last week
September 22 — Zelensky and Trump met in New York. Zelensky said Ukraine was ready for reciprocal restraint on energy attacks and that no unilateral halt to Ukrainian attacks on Russian refineries had been discussed.
Evidence · 4 source statements
On Tuesday, September 22, Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky met in New York to discuss the war in Ukraine.
"We are ready for any kind of format of energy ceasefire"
"not attack our energy system,"
The Ukrainian president said Kyiv was ready for any format of energy truce with Russia but that there had been no discussion of Ukraine unilaterally halting its attacks on…
Russia said it would accept the proposed truce only if Western energy sanctions were lifted first.
Evidence · 1 source statement
Russia said it could only go along with Trump's energy truce proposal if Western energy sanctions on Moscow were lifted first.
Rubio said the United States would try to help broker a halt to energy attacks, while warning that an agreement would be difficult.
Evidence · 3 source statements
Later, at a news conference, Rubio said the Trump administration would try to get both sides to reach an agreement to halt attacks on Russian oil infrastructure and Ukrainian…
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,”
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,” he said, acknowledging that reaching such an agreement would not be easy, given that both sides…
What was reported
Zelensky and Trump met in New York on September 22 on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly; Zelensky said they discussed ending the war and a possible ceasefire covering energy targets.
Reported independently by 2: CBC News, France 24
Evidence · 2 source statements
On Tuesday, September 22, Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky met in New York to discuss the war in Ukraine.
Zelenskyy told reporters after the meeting that the two met for 40 minutes and discussed how to end the four-year-old war as well as the potential for a bilateral ceasefire on…
Zelensky said a unilateral Ukrainian halt to attacks on Russian oil refineries had not been discussed.
Reported independently by 2: CBC News, South China Morning Post
Evidence · 2 source statements
The Ukrainian president said Kyiv was ready for any format of energy truce with Russia but that there had been no discussion of Ukraine unilaterally halting its attacks on…
there had been no discussion of Ukraine unilaterally halting its attacks on Russian oil refineries.
Trump predicted a broader deal but did not disclose its terms.
One source: TASS
Evidence · 2 source statements
I think they're going to make a deal
I don't want to say what the deal is.
Trump said Russia and Ukraine had agreed not to target each other’s energy infrastructure.
Reported independently by 2: AP, CNews
Evidence · 2 source statements
Trump last week asserted that he got the two sides to agree to not target each other's energy infrastructure.
Russia said it would accept Trump’s energy-truce proposal only if Western energy sanctions on Moscow were lifted first.
One source: AP
Evidence · 1 source statement
Russia said it could only go along with Trump's energy truce proposal if Western energy sanctions on Moscow were lifted first.
Rubio said Washington would try to help Russia and Ukraine halt attacks on Russian oil and Ukrainian electrical infrastructure, but that reaching a deal would be difficult because both sides viewed the targets as strategically important.
One source: EFE
Evidence · 3 source statements
Later, at a news conference, Rubio said the Trump administration would try to get both sides to reach an agreement to halt attacks on Russian oil infrastructure and Ukrainian…
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,”
“We will try. I think we are prepared to play a positive role in achieving it,” he said, acknowledging that reaching such an agreement would not be easy, given that both sides…
Zelensky proposed a trilateral summit with Trump and Putin to seek an end to the war.
One source: Hürriyet
Evidence · 1 source statement
Still unclear
No agreement to halt attacks on energy infrastructure was announced at the Trump-Zelensky meeting.
Whether attacks on energy infrastructure stopped is unknown.
Whether Western energy sanctions were lifted is unknown.
Donald Trump and Volodymyr Zelensky met in New York during the UN General Assembly to discuss ending the war, including a possible reciprocal halt to attacks on energy sites. Trump predicted a deal but did not disclose its terms; Zelensky said the meeting produced no agreement and urged an end to the war before winter.
Volodymyr Zelensky and Donald Trump met in New York on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly, then held a closed session. Zelensky said Ukraine was ready for a reciprocal halt to attacks on energy infrastructure and called for a meeting with Trump and Vladimir Putin; he also said diplomatic and military-support discussions were continuing.
Donald Trump said Russia and Ukraine had agreed to stop attacking each other’s energy infrastructure, describing it as an energy truce. Russia said it would accept the proposal only if Western sanctions were lifted; Trump also blamed the war for rising global diesel prices.
Marco Rubio said Washington would try to help Russia and Ukraine agree to stop attacks on energy infrastructure, while warning that an agreement would be difficult because both sides view the targets as strategically important. He also voiced concern that the war could spread to other countries through sabotage, hybrid attacks or accidental incidents.
Volodymyr Zelensky said Ukraine was ready for an energy ceasefire if Russia agreed not to attack Ukraine’s energy system. He said he did not know Moscow’s position and wanted the United States to convey the proposal to Russia.