glade.news

Judge orders White House to restore access for three news outlets

24 articles · 18 outlets (3 relaying others' reporting) · 13 countries · Sources | Summary

A federal judge temporarily blocked the Trump administration’s restrictions on CNN, MS NOW and Politico, ordering their White House access restored for 14 days while their legal challenge proceeds. Judge Timothy Kelly said the outlets were likely to show that the administration had not provided adequate due process, and that its national-security justification lacked factual support.

Countries involved United States · 2 outlets

First reported among our outlets by Daily Jang (Pakistan), · most coverage from United States (2), United Kingdom (2), South Korea (2), India (2)

Photo via BBC News

What the parties said

Statements by officials of the countries involved, as the outlets reported them. Each links to the article it comes from.

United States

saying his ban on the three media outlets was likely unconstitutional.

Also reported by 2 other outlets

The record lacks factual support for defendants' contention that the revocation of plaintiffs' hard passes will in fact protect national security or that national security will…

Tim Kelly, quoted in NDTV
Also reported by 1 other outlet

This is a strong ruling vindicating freedom of the press, due process, and the rule of law.

Theodore J. Boutrous, quoted in NPR

Coverage

Group by Photos

The groupings and the short descriptions in orange are automated. How this works

Fox News · United States24 Sep 06:02

Federal judge orders Trump administration to restore White House access to CNN, MS NOW and Politico

Reports government's access-is-privilege defense

Lawyers for the Justice Department argued that White House press access is a privilege, not a right, and defended the president's authority to determine who receives access.

Fox News, reporting Lawyers for the Justice Department
NPR · United States24 Sep 11:10

Judge restores journalists' White House access. And, Tucker Carlson on his MAGA split

Notes cited reporting lacked evidence of harm

Judge Kelly said the defendants hadn't offered evidence to explain how "any of the reporting they identified in their letters to Plaintiffs damaged national security."

NPR, reporting U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly
Asahi Shimbun · Japan24 Sep 08:00

Was the seizure of White House press passes from CNN and others unconstitutional? District court orders them reinstated

Translated from: CNNなどのホワイトハウス記者証、没収は違憲か 地裁が復活を決定
Highlights Fifth Amendment notice and hearing
The Hankyoreh · South Korea

Trump Kicked CNN Out Under the Pretext of ‘Fake News’… Court: “Allow It Access”

Translated from: ‘가짜뉴스’ 핑계로 CNN 쫓아낸 트럼프…법원 “출입 허용하라”
Highlights unsupported national-security claim
Yonhap News Agency · South Korea24 Sep 07:16

Federal court halts White House ban on CNN and other media outlets

Translated from: CNN 등 언론사 백악관 출입금지 연방법원서 제동
Features outlets' viewpoint-discrimination claim
2 more from Yonhap News Agency [US-China summit] US TV cameras go dark… Trump: “China has a friendly press corps”U.S. court dismisses Trump's 'polling fraud' lawsuit against local newspaper
France 24 · France24 Sep 05:31

US judge lifts Trump’s White House ban on CNN, MS NOW, Politico

Summarizes judge's likely-unconstitutional finding

saying his ban on the three media outlets was likely unconstitutional.

France 24, reporting Tim Kelly
Der Spiegel · Germany24 Sep 06:28

US judge lifts Trump’s media ban against CNN and Politico

Translated from: Gegen CNN und Politico: US-Richter hebt Trumps Medien-Bann auf
Reports Trump's criticism of media coverage
Deutsche Welle · Germany24 Sep 16:41

CNN, MS NOW, Politico regain access to White House

Highlights court's rejection of security claims

"The record lacks factual support for defendants’ contention that the revocation of plaintiffs' hard passes will in fact protect national security or that national security will…

Tim Kelly, quoted in Deutsche Welle
BBC News · United Kingdom24 Sep 05:57

Judge temporarily overturns Trump's White House media ban

Notes Trump initially omitted national security

He also cast doubt on the Trump administration's arguments that the bans were motivated by national security concerns, pointing out the president made no mention of that in his…

BBC News, reporting Timothy Kelly
The Guardian · United Kingdom24 Sep 05:25

Judge orders Trump White House to restore access to CNN, MS Now and Politico

Reports DOJ defense of revocation letters

the Trump administration provided a sufficient explanation for the revocation of the press passes in letters sent to the news outlets on Tuesday.

The Guardian, reporting Justice Department
Clarín · Argentina24 Sep 05:50

Court orders White House access restored for media outlets barred by Trump

Translated from: La justicia ordena restablecer el acceso a la Casa Blanca de los medios vetados por Trump
Relays CNN
Relays CNN's account of restoration order
3 more from Clarín CNN and Politico remain barred from the White House despite a court ruling overturning the banU.S. judge orders White House to restore access to CNN, MS NOW and PoliticoIowa judge dismisses Trump’s lawsuit against a pollster and a media outlet
teleSUR English · Venezuela24 Sep 16:37

Judge Kelly Orders Trump to Restore Media Access to the White House

Relays EFE, Politico, The New York Times
Adds deadline for explaining noncompliance

Kelly set a deadline of 12:30 p.m. local time to receive explanations for the failure to comply with the order

teleSUR English, reporting Kyle Cheney, via Politico
The Times of Israel · Israel24 Sep 20:11

CNN, MS NOW, Politico allowed back at White House after judge ordered Trump to lift ban

Relays Associated Press
Relays AP's access-as-privilege argument

“Access to the White House is a privilege, not a right,”

Michael Velchik, quoted in The Times of Israel
CBC News · Canada24 Sep 08:48

White House reporters from outlets banned by Trump regain access after hours-long delay

Quotes lawyer on press freedom and due process

"This is a strong ruling vindicating freedom of the press, due process and the rule of law,"

Theodore Boutrous Jr., quoted in CBC News
RIA Novosti · Russia24 Sep 17:14

CNN and MS NOW regain access to the White House, along with Politico

Translated from: Телеканалам СNN, MSNOW и изданию Politico вернули доступ в Белый дом
Highlights further hearings during 14 days
NDTV · India24 Sep 06:17

US Judge Lifts Trump's White House Ban On CNN, MS NOW, Politico

Includes DOJ defense of revocation letters

the Trump administration provided a sufficient explanation for the revocation of the press passes in letters sent to the news outlets on Tuesday.

NDTV, reporting A Justice Department lawyer
The Hindu · India25 Sep 04:29
Explainer

Why did a U.S. court stay Trump’s ban on media outlets?

Notes court called White House objections vague

“so vague that it hardly does the trick”

Tim Kelly, quoted in The Hindu
1 more from The Hindu CNN, MS NOW, Politico allowed back in White House after judge’s order
Daily Jang · Pakistan24 Sep 05:09

Court ends Trump-imposed ban, restores White House access for journalists from all three media organizations

Translated from: عدالت نے ٹرمپ کی لگائی گئی پابندی ختم کر دی، تینوں میڈیا اداروں کے صحافیوں کی وائٹ ہاؤس آمد بحال
Emphasizes notice and appeal protections

Covered in

ArgentinaCanadaFranceGermanyIndiaIsraelJapanPakistanRussiaSouth KoreaUnited KingdomUnited StatesVenezuela

Headlines and excerpts are the outlets' own and link to the original articles. Non-English headlines are machine-translated. The photo and logos load from the publishers' sites. Generated summary