glade.news

Justice Department defends White House media access bans in court

12 articles · 10 outlets (1 relaying others' reporting) · 8 countries · Sources | Summary

The Justice Department filed a court argument defending restrictions on CNN, MS NOW and Politico’s access to parts of the White House. It said the president had authority to control access and argued that some of the outlets’ reporting raised national-security concerns.

Countries involved United States · 0 of our 3 outlets

First reported among our outlets by Clarín (Argentina), · most coverage from United Kingdom (1), Spain (1), South Korea (1), Russia (1)

Photo via BBC News

What the parties said

Statements by officials of the countries involved, as the outlets reported them. Each links to the article it comes from.

United States

access to the White House is a privilege, not an entitlement, and that the president has the authority to suspend access by news organizations.

Also reported by 2 other outlets

The US Justice Department has filed documents that accuse three media outlets banned from the White House of "trafficking in verifiable falsehoods" and reporting which…

BBC News, citing U.S. Justice Department

According to a court filing by the Justice Department in a District of Columbia court, the three outlets were issued with a list of "reporting incidents" by the White House ahead…

BBC News, citing U.S. Justice Department

Coverage

Group by Photos

The groupings and the short descriptions in orange are automated. How this works

Yonhap News Agency · South Korea23 Sep 06:43

U.S. Justice Department: “Barring media outlets from access is a presidential power… reporting on the Iran war is a security threat”

Translated from: 美법무부 "언론사 출입금지 대통령 권한…이란전 보도가 안보위협"
Adds CNN's account of prior court rulings
Le Monde · France23 Sep 09:52

Access to the White House is “a privilege, not a right,” Trump administration says after journalists are barred

Translated from: L’accès à la Maison Blanche est « un privilège, pas un droit », juge l’administration Trump après l’exclusion de journalistes
Highlights government control of restricted areas
Deutsche Welle · Germany24 Sep 16:41

CNN, MS NOW, Politico regain access to White House

On Tuesday, the Justice Department had argued in a filing that access to the White House was a privilege, not an entitlement, and that the president had the authority to deny…

Deutsche Welle, citing Justice Department
El País · Spain24 Sep 04:00
Analysis

To renovate the White House or bar journalists: national security, Trump’s pretext for pushing through his most controversial plans

Translated from: Para reformar la Casa Blanca o vetar a periodistas: la seguridad nacional, el ardid de Trump para desbloquear sus planes más polémicos
BBC News · United Kingdom23 Sep 06:47

Trump administration accuses banned media outlets of 'falsehoods' ahead of court hearing

Leads with accusations of falsehoods and security threats

The US Justice Department has filed documents that accuse three media outlets banned from the White House of "trafficking in verifiable falsehoods" and reporting which…

BBC News, citing U.S. Justice Department
The Guardian · United Kingdom24 Sep 05:25

Judge orders Trump White House to restore access to CNN, MS Now and Politico

Leads with order restoring newsroom access

access to the White House is a privilege, not an entitlement, and that the president has the authority to suspend access by news organizations.

The Guardian, reporting Justice Department
Clarín · Argentina23 Sep 08:50

Justice Department defends Trump’s barring of media access to the White House

Translated from: Departamento de Justicia defiende que Trump vete acceso de medios a la Casa Blanca
Adds context on Trump's attacks against critical media
1 more from Clarín Justice Department backs Trump’s ban on media outlets “for security reasons”
RIA Novosti · Russia23 Sep 06:59

U.S. Justice Department says Trump has the right to deny media access to the White House

Translated from: Минюст США заявил, что Трамп вправе отказать СМИ в доступе в Белый дом
Emphasizes presidential discretion and national security
1 more from RIA Novosti CNN and MS NOW regain access to the White House, along with Politico
NDTV · India24 Sep 06:17

US Judge Lifts Trump's White House Ban On CNN, MS NOW, Politico

Leads with judge lifting the ban

access to the White House is a privilege, not an entitlement, and that the president has the authority to suspend access by news organizations.

NDTV, reporting Justice Department
The Hindu · India22 Sep 13:54

Trump's White House media ban faces long odds in court, legal experts say

Relays Reuters
Relays Reuters legal experts' court outlook

Where accounts differ

Different readings

Whether the president may restrict news organizations’ White House access

The Justice Department argued that the president has authority to restrict access, including to protected areas.

CNN said courts had sided with the press when the administration tried to remove media outlets’ White House access.

Covered in

ArgentinaFranceGermanyIndiaRussiaSouth KoreaSpainUnited Kingdom

Headlines and excerpts are the outlets' own and link to the original articles. Non-English headlines are machine-translated. The photo and logos load from the publishers' sites. Generated summary